I often see people talking about the fact that they like a certain open-source application, but ‘it’s a shame it’s on Electron’; what does this mean? Is it a privacy thing or a resource thing?

@Echedenyan@lemmy.ml
link
fedilink
20
edit-2
2Y

Electron is a framework for desktop development based on Chromium.

It has a big part of Chromium as part of its code but with a wrapper layer to act as a framework.

With it, you can make desktop apps with PWA (Progressive Web Apps).

They like some of it because you can get the beauty of CSS and JS effects in a desktop app, but for every of these apps you end running an independent instance of Chromium.

It doesn’t use system browser engine or one from the installed browsers. Every app you install using it is exactly the same as installing Chrome or Chromium in different folders at your PC and running them at the same time.

This is why they blame it too.

If you have to use more than one Electron app, Ferdi is pretty great https://getferdi.com/

Thank you for pointing this out. Atm I only use Discord (bc my friends “lIkE tHiR UI” and refuse to use mumble…) bit if I had to go through the pain of using more electron crap I think that that app would be a cool solution

I haven’t tried it yet, but Fosscord seems like it could be handy for Discord rehab treatment (especially if the incredible-sounding “connect to discord.com servers” works)

I didn’t know it was already usable. Thanks

Electron apps is essentially running web apps wrapped as a desktop version. Most of them run like garbage and are always inferior to one made specifically for desktops. The only one I’ve used that runs sensibly is Discord.

As for why people use it, it’s convenient for developers as most of them are familiar with web development and can essentially copy-paste their web application without having to change much.

Electron apps is essentially running web apps wrapped as a desktop version.

worse even: it includes different copies of chromium in each app

Helix 🧬
link
fedilink
32Y

Yeah, and since the devs obviously are either too inept to change this or don’t care, they probably never will – this “idea about a runtime mode” issue is open since 2014.

2014 was the same year Microsoft ended support for Windows XP.

Nathan John Cooper
creator
link
fedilink
12Y

So, I assume there’s not an Electron alternative that is able to port internet desktop applications without any privacy or resource issues?

There is Tauri which is very similar but claims to have a lower resource usage and be more secure.

There isn’t an alternative, Electron actually does its job well for what it is. It’s basically a slimmed down browser that’s customizable and runs on all systems, it’s just that it takes a ton of effort to optimize it, and for some reason most people using it aren’t very experienced.

Voxl
link
fedilink
42Y

Here are some flaws with Electron:

  • High RAM and CPU consumption since it’s based on Chromium
  • Electron apps take too much space as they’re bundled with NodeJS and Chromium runtine
  • Electron apps tend to be slow
  • Terrible sucurity
Nathan John Cooper
creator
link
fedilink
32Y

Ahhh, I see; so, essentially, a combination of both resources and privacy.

Nathan John Cooper
creator
link
fedilink
22Y

Thanks.

@jokeyrhyme@lemmy.ml
link
fedilink
0
edit-2
2Y

An Electron app has full access to your filesystem and to other system resources, the same as any other desktop app

Is there a specific reason or example for why we say it has terrible security here?

Chromium has an incredibly advanced and optimised graphics pipeline and the code that is running in the “web” part of an Electron app benefits from Chromium’s sandbox

AgreeableLandscape☭
banned
link
fedilink
5
edit-2
2Y

removed by mod

You mean how like nobody ever ever pipes the output of curl into a bash with root privileges? :P

Maybe we should ban cURL when we ban Electron?

AgreeableLandscape☭
banned
link
fedilink
7
edit-2
2Y

removed by mod

I guess a better parallel is using C/C++ to write software, where it is trivially easy to mismanaged memory in ways that cause 70% of CVEs

If we were being consistent, we’d be trying to eliminate all software written in any language or framework where it is trivially easy to introduce security issues

I wonder how many anti-Electron folks are also logically anti-C/C++ ?

AgreeableLandscape☭
banned
link
fedilink
1
edit-2
2Y

removed by mod

Well, electron just sucks. Is just trash. Inmense resource consumption bc chromium.

Dessalines
link
fedilink
82Y

I always like to think of the fact that space agencies went to the moon on like 2KB of ram, but in 2022 we need 4 GB of ram to run a chat window.

“But nowdays is cheaper” it’s a lazy excuse to not do any proper optimization.

Dessalines
link
fedilink
62Y

That article that @IngrownMink4@lemmy.ml linked is so good. At the bottom of it, they state: “All you web devs should learn C or Rust. Your program runs on a computer. Learn how to code for one.”

AgreeableLandscape☭
banned
link
fedilink
6
edit-2
2Y

removed by mod

Truth is though, if you made a app that looked as good and could resize itself just as good it would probably be more resource intensive.

If you just have a few input boxes though, its a waste to use electron.

People complain about Electron, but without it there would probably be even fewer cross-platform apps today

Some aspects of it might be less than perfect, but let’s not allow perfect to be the enemy of good

Electron doesn’t automatically mean that an app is bad, just like Unity doesn’t automatically mean that a game is good

Completely agree, thanks to Electron we now have many mainstream apps working on Linux and that just wouldn’t have happened otherwise. Whatever technological problems Electron has can be addressed down the road, and are outweighed by the value of lowering the barrier of creating cross-platform applications.

AgreeableLandscape☭
banned
link
fedilink
9
edit-2
2Y

removed by mod

IngrownMink4
link
fedilink
62Y

You mean something similar to XULRunner?

Pluggable engines would be nice, but I feel like it’s less of a concern for stuff like Electron where you’re making apps with it. I’d be more interested in addressing memory usage and cutting out stuff that’s not really needed for apps that’s part of the browser engine. Ideally, it should be modular so that you can include just the stuff your app uses to keep it lean. Perhaps using an approach similar to GraalVM could be taken as well to reduce resource usage.

Helix 🧬
link
fedilink
22Y

Or you could just use the offline functionality built into browsers nowadays instead of Electron.

AgreeableLandscape☭
banned
link
fedilink
23
edit-2
2Y

removed by mod

All about open source! Feel free to ask questions, and share news, and interesting stuff!

Useful Links

Rules

  • Posts must be relevant to the open source ideology
  • No NSFW content
  • No hate speech, bigotry, etc

Related Communities

Community icon from opensource.org, but we are not affiliated with them.

  • 0 users online
  • 5 users / day
  • 14 users / week
  • 19 users / month
  • 6 users / 6 months
  • 22 subscribers
  • 584 Posts
  • 1.24K Comments
  • Modlog